91 Martin Street

Timeless Elegance Meets Modern Comfort in the Heart of Downtown Jefferson! Room to Add a Pool | Historic Main Home + Luxury Carriage House Step into a perfect blend of history, charm, and modern sophistication in this beautifully restored 1909 Jefferson gem-once the parsonage of the Jefferson Methodist Church. Ideally situated in the heart of downtown, the property offers rare Historic Courthouse views, walkability to shops, dining, and entertainment, and is located in the top-rated Jefferson City School district. This unique property includes two distinct residences: a grand historic Main House and a custom-designed 2022 Carriage House, set on a professionally landscaped 1/2-acre lot with room to add a pool. The Main House welcomes you with a large, classic front porch and gracious Southern-style foyer featuring a sweeping 3/4-turn staircase and original stained-glass window. The living room (Parlor) boasts an intricate two-tiered mantel, while the formal Dining Room includes a fireplace, seating for 12, and a built-in bar or china cabinet. The chef-inspired kitchen is both functional and striking, featuring a copper farm sink, Caesarstone and butcher block counters, custom vent hood, and stainless appliances including a French door fridge, wall oven, and beverage fridge. A walk-in pantry and stylish laundry room add utility, while newly added vaulted Family and Breakfast Rooms create a warm, light-filled gathering space anchored by a fireplace and 1800s reclaimed mantel. The main-level Primary Suite is a serene retreat with spa-like bath: original clawfoot tub, oversized shower, dual closets, and new custom walk-in. Upstairs includes three large bedrooms-each with its own unique fireplace and original architectural details/built-ins, plus a fully renovated bath, ample storage, and a versatile bonus room. The wide upstairs hallway opens to the bedrooms and the unique flexible bonus space (once the pastor's writing nook).. ideal for a playroom, office, or study. Throughout the home, you'll find beautiful hardwood floors-some original, others seamlessly added to match the era. A detached two-car garage connects to the Main House via a breezeway and offers wide drive access and extra parking. The 2022 Carriage House complements the historic home with timeless architecture and modern flair. Inside: rich hardwoods, vaulted tongue-and-groove ceilings, shiplap walls, and custom finishes. The open-plan living/dining area leads to a high-end kitchen with quartz counters, stainless appliances, and glass-front cabinetry. The spa-like ensuite includes a clawfoot tub and wet-room shower. A large laundry room (washer/dryer included) adds convenience, and the bedroom opens to a private patio and fenced yard-ideal for guests or multigenerational living. Outdoor living is magical: from bricked patio spaces under cafe lights to lush turf, garden boxes, a whimsical 14-ft hill slide, and shaded treed areas. The landscape bursts with hundreds of spring perennials-tulips, lilies, azaleas, hostas, hydrangeas-framed by historic magnolias, dogwoods, and pecan trees. Boulder walls, stone steps, a vintage potting bench, and even a solar chandelier hanging from a pecan tree add to the storybook charm. Additional Features: * Room to add a pool * Newly sided, wrapped, & painted (2023) * New breezeway from garage to home * Tankless water heater * Two fully encapsulated crawl spaces (one with storage) * New upstairs HVAC * Roofs: 10 yrs (main) & 3 yrs (carriage) * Restored wavy glass windows, reglazed & preserved * Pine hardwoods throughout both homes * 3 NEST thermostats * Featured on Jefferson's Christmas Tour of Homes & PorchFest * Steps to schools, shops, restaurants, library, festivals * 20 mins to Athens, Gainesville, Braselton, Buford. This is more than a home-it's a piece of Jefferson's legacy w/ historic character, luxurious updates, TOP schools, a real community & walkable to everything Jefferson... it is a lifestyle!